[Sosfbay-discuss] Forget Alex Walker -- Read Gary Kamiya

[Andrea Dorey]

KPFA mentioned on one of the AM shows that the difference between how  
McCain's response to a very similar situation was rather interesting  
in view of Obama's determination to even withdraw from the church if  
his former pastor didn't.  Here I was thinking how brave Obama was  
not to go overboard but still deal with it in a rational way and now  
I hear this.

We really have lost the concept of being able to seriously disagree  
with one another and still be able to discuss (and even agree on)  
other subjects, haven't we?

KPFA also commented on the different environment we are in with  
Winter Soldier II and the environment when Winter Soldier was in  
legislative hearings.  Kerry (when asked) didn't know WS II was going  
on!!  (Was it his clone that testified in the first one???)
Andrea

On Mar 25, 2008, at 9:54 AM, alexcathy at aol.com wrote:

> Forget Alex Walker. Who the hell is he, anyway? A failed computer  
> programmer! Instead, read Gary Kamiya's excellent essay posted on  
> www.salon.com today. Kamiya says almost everything I was trying to  
> say in my post last week, when everybody shot me down as a "troll"  
> and a general madman. Truth is truth, even if a madman says it.   
> Gary Kamiya makes the same point much better than me and since Mr.  
> Kamiya is executive editor and cofounder of the online magazine  
> Salon.com, and a regular contributor to The New York Times Book  
> Review, unlike me, he has a proper corporate license to express an  
> opinion.  I have deleted my entire essay from the Green Commons Web  
> Site and substituted Gary Kamiya' because I think this so  
> important. Kamiya begins right away with the terrifying spectre of  
> President John McCain.  Also note the powerful quote from Abraham  
> Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address which today's ignorant US  
> "intellectuals" never remember.
>
>
> Posted on Salon, Tuesday, March 25, 2008.
> Rev. Jeremiah Wright Isn't the Problem
> The hysteria over Obama's former pastor's attacks on America shows  
> we're still in thrall to knee-jerk patriotism.
> by Gary Kamiya
>
> Maybe we really are doomed to elect John McCain, remain in Iraq  
> forever and nuke Iran. Nations that forget history may not be  
> doomed to repeat it, but those that never even recognize reality in  
> the first place definitely are. Last week's ridiculous uproar over  
> Rev. Jeremiah Wright's sermons proves yet again that America has  
> still not come to terms with the most rudimentary facts about race,  
> 9/11 -- or itself.
>
> The great shock so many people claim to be feeling over Wright's  
> sermons is preposterous. Anyone who is surprised and horrified that  
> some black people feel anger at white people, and America, is  
> living in a racial never-never land.
> Wright has called the U.S. "the United States of White America,"  
> talks about the "oppression" of black people and says, "White  
> America got their wake-up call after 9/11." Gosh, who could have  
> dreamed that angry racial grievances and left-wing political views  
> are sometimes expressed in black churches?
>
> It's not surprising that the right is using Wright to paint Barack  
> Obama as a closet Farrakhan, trying to let the air out of his trans- 
> racial balloon by insinuating that he's a dogmatic race man. But  
> beyond the fake shock and the all-too-familiar racial politics,  
> what the whole episode reveals is how narrow the range of  
> acceptable discourse remains in this country. This is especially  
> true of anything having to do with patriotism or 9/11 -- which have  
> become virtually interchangeable. Wright's unforgivable sin was  
> that he violated our rigid code of national etiquette.
> . . .
>
> Wright isn't the problem. Stupid patriotism is the problem.
>
> We are now five years into a war that may outrank Vietnam as the  
> most pointless and disastrous one in our history. George W. Bush  
> and his neoconservative brain trust conceived that war, but they  
> were only able to push it through because the American people,  
> their political leaders and the mainstream media signed off on it.  
> And they did so because they were in the grip of the fearful,  
> vengeful, patriotic frenzy that swept the nation after 9/11.  
> Without 9/11 and America's fateful reaction to it, there would be  
> no Iraq war. Every day that the war drags on is yet another  
> indictment of that self-righteous, unthinking "patriotism."
> . . .
>
> In fact, the same all-American flag-wavers who called loudest for  
> war against Iraq are now denouncing Wright as a hate-monger and a  
> traitor, and attacking Michelle Obama for saying that only recently  
> has she had reason to feel proud of her country. They insist that  
> anyone who is not permanently proud of the United States, whose  
> patriotism isn't plastered on his or her face like the frozen smile  
> of a beauty queen waving from a Fourth of July float, is beyond the  
> pale. Never mind that the glorious results of their debased version  
> of patriotism -- 4,000 American troops dead, a wrecked Iraq, and a  
> greatly trengthened terrorist enemy -- are plain for all to see.
> . . .
>
> Yes, Wright was angry, shrill and one-sided. But America would have  
> been better off if his uncomfortable sermon had echoed through  
> every church in the country after 9/11, instead of the patriotic,  
> ahistorical pablum that did.
> That's strange, and depressing, is that all this has happened  
> before -- and we've learned nothing. In the days after 9/11, the  
> nation whipped itself up into an ecstasy of moral sanctimony. Among  
> the few who dared to resist the groupthink was Susan Sontag, who in  
> a brief New Yorker piece wrote, "The disconnect between last  
> Tuesday's monstrous dose of reality and the self-righteous drivel  
> and outright deceptions being peddled by public figures and TV  
> commentators is startling, depressing. The voices licensed to  
> follow the event seem to have joined together in a campaign to  
> infantilize the public. Where is the acknowledgement that this was  
> not a 'cowardly' attack on 'civilization' or 'liberty' or  
> 'humanity' or 'the free world' but an attack on the world's self- 
> proclaimed super-power, undertaken as a consequence of specific  
> American alliances and actions?"
> . . .
>
> The taboo against any critical national self-examination has always  
> existed here. But 9/11 sealed it in blood and made it virtually  
> untouchable. Only a few academics, Middle East specialists and  
> outspoken journalists have dared to suggest that U.S. foreign  
> policies played a role in the 9/11 attacks. The Democrats,  
> terrified of being called unpatriotic and "weak on national  
> security," won't go there. Which is a big reason that the  
> desperately needed national discussion over how to deal with the  
> Arab/Muslim world after Bush leaves office still hasn't started.
>
> Turkey has a notorious law, Article 301, that makes "insulting  
> Turkishness" a crime. We're a lot closer to this than we like to  
> think. In fact, we can expect John McCain's entire campaign to  
> basically be an American version of Article 301.
> . . .
>
> The Prophetic Tradition
>
> In 1630, Winthrop delivered a sermon to his fellow members of the  
> Massachusetts Bay Company. The line that has gone down in history,  
> oft cited by Ronald Reagan, is "wee shall be as a Citty upon a  
> Hill." But Reagan, eager to present America as perfect, omitted the  
> passage that followed. Winthrop warned that if the community of  
> Puritans dealt falsely with their God, they would be cursed "till  
> wee be consumed out of the good land whether wee are goeing."
> . . .
>
> In his Second Inaugural Address, delivered near the end of the  
> Civil War, Abraham Lincoln issued an equally terrifying warning --  
> one also largely erased from the national memory. "Fondly do we  
> hope -- fervently do we pray that this mighty scourge of war may  
> speedily pass away," Lincoln said. But then he added, "Yet, if God  
> wills that it continue, until all the wealth piled by the bond- 
> man's two hundred and fifty years of unrequited toil shall be sunk,  
> and until every drop of blood drawn with the lash, shall be paid by  
> another drawn with the sword, as was said three thousand years ago,  
> so still it must be said 'the judgments of the Lord, are true and  
> righteous altogether.'"
> . . .
>
> I am not comparing Jeremiah Wright to these towering figures. My  
> point is that his angry claims that his nation has betrayed its  
> promises of racial equality and a just foreign policy are part of a  
> long and honorable prophetic tradition. It was not critics like  
> Wright who got us into the bloody mess we're in today. That honor  
> belongs to the flag-wavers, the patriots -- "the real Americans."
>
>
>
> URL: http://www.salon.com/opinion/kamiya/2008/03/25/ 
> rev_jeremiah_wright/
>
>
> Gary Kamiya is the executive editor and one of the founders of the  
> online magazine Salon.com, where he has written about politics,  
> literature, the Middle East, sports, music, art, race, travel, and  
> film, among other subjects, and is a regular contributor to The New  
> York Times Book Review.
> Planning your summer road trip? Check out AOL Travel Guides.
> _______________________________________________
> sosfbay-discuss mailing list
> sosfbay-discuss at cagreens.org
> http://lists.cagreens.org/mailman/listinfo/sosfbay-discuss

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.cagreens.org/pipermail/sosfbay-discuss_lists.cagreens.org/attachments/20080328/d43647c3/attachment.html>