[GPSCC-chat] The Greatest Generation?
Brian
snug.bug at hotmail.com
Wed Nov 13 12:26:40 PST 2013
My finger was pointed first of all at myself, though I'll suppose that wasn't obvious.
I found Professor Boyle's view provocative because I had arrived at that perception myself just a few days earlier in a discussion of militarism wherein one party started bragging about what a war hero his dad had been in WWII and for the first time in all these decades it occurred to me to ask "Well, didn't your war hero dad ever tell you that war is hell? And why not?"
Why were the war heroes silent in the Vietnam controversy? Why was there no Smedley Butler of the 1960s to take General Eisenhower's warnings about the Military Industrial Complex and run with them, and stand with Martin Luther King when he denounced Imperialism in his Riverside speech in 1967? Of course we had the Winter Soldier hearings and the VVAW, but why did the Greatest Generation snub them?
As don't recall any effort to convince us that the war was right, but only the bald assertion that a communist Vietnam would be bad for America, and a lot of platitudes about duty and sacrifice and the price of freedom with no attempt at all to make a logical case for the war.
My rant about my deGeneration was born of my frustration at having accomplished nothing in almost ten years of full-time activism, which I attribute to a prevailing attitude of selfish, smug, and highly self-serving cynicism and apathy among those who have the skills and the resources to make a difference if they wanted to. They anger me because for twenty years I was one of them. I didn't even bother to vote most of the time, didn't even know Nader was running in 2000, didn't know about the mass mobe against the Iraq war until after it was over. It was because of my selfish apathy during those years, and the selfish apathy of a hundred million like me, that this country got so deep in Doo Doo Creek that we're starting to feel at home in it. So I come to my activism work out of obligation to take responsibility for the mess that I created.
Where did those 100,000 people go who demonstrated in San Francisco against the Iraq war? How come we could never get more than 1200 to lie down on the beach on a beautiful summer Sunday to demonstrate for impeachment? There was a time when I idealized Carol Brouillet as something like the Lone Cypress, standing in the gale with the waves crashing around, and I believed that by standing as an inspiration to resistance she could make a distance. I'm starting to feel that I've been swimming against the current in Doo Doo Creek for so long that I no longer even care that I'm getting nowhere.
Date: Wed, 13 Nov 2013 11:26:26 -0800
From: eric at philosopherswheel.com
To: sosfbay-discuss at cagreens.org
Subject: Re: [GPSCC-chat] The Greatest Generation?
Good comments Sandy. I agree
generations blaming ewach other is useless. I do point the finger
at the people though; it is up to them not to be misled, and it
shouldn't be that difficult. McCarthyism could be cited correctly
for blame on the war policies, although it was also because the
military industrial complex responded habitually to communist
threats (Truman and Johnson were not followers of McCarthy, but
they did follow the complex's interests). Communism had some good
points about controlling runaway capitalist greed, but its
totalitarian methods and materialist values don't make it a viable
method at all. But a better balance between socialism and
capitalism that creates real rather than phony "freedom" and
unequal prosperity, is being proposed now, and in the next
decade-plus it will be put forward by Greens and others.
The Green values and platforms are an excellent roadmap of where
we need to go. Green represents an advance on both democratic
capitalism and socialism, taking the best of both and creating a
new synthesis beyond the Marxist one. It respects the spiritual
and inherent values of life, and brings individual freedom and
collective responsibility into an ecology-like interaction and
inter-dependence, like the person and the environment nourishing
each other.
Eric the Green
On 11/11/2013 5:44 PM, perrysandy at aol.com wrote:
I think it is wrong and actually
divisive for generations to point the finger at each other
and cast blame. The blame lies with the corporate capitalist
system, not with the American people who have been misled by
politicians, the corporate media, and our
corporate-controlled education system. The "greatest
generation" WAS great - how many of us would leave our
families and communities for four or five years and risk our
lives to defend what they understood was democracy and
freedom?
The greatest generation was ruined by McCarthyism pure and
simple. Political debate in America, which thrived from the
late 19th century (and earlier) up through the early 1940s,
was effectively ended. Communists, socialists, and their
"fellow-travelers" were hounded out of Hollywood, the print
media, radio, and every available means of communication, not
to mention unions, community organizations, cultural groups,
and even social clubs. When the left was shut out of the
debate - as surely as Jill Stein and Cheri Honkala were shut
out of the presidential debates - no wonder the result was war
and "mindless patriotism".
We still suffer from McCarthyism today, where millions of
people continue to believe communism is a "criminal
conspiracy" as Nixon called it, rather than a viable and
idealistic alternative to our broken economy. It is up to us
to not be afraid to put forward radical solutions to society's
problems. I joined the Greens because they are not afraid to
be different - as they say, the color of courage is green.
I think conditions today are actually more favorable than
ever for proposing a new economic paradigm. For most people in
the greatest generation, capitalism actually worked (see
"Capitalism - A Love Story"). Now it is broken, failing to
provide a living for millions and failing to protect the
environment. It is time for people like us to step forward and
change the world!
Sandy
-----Original Message-----
From: Brian <snug.bug at hotmail.com>
To: sosfbay-discuss <sosfbay-discuss at cagreens.org>
Sent: Mon, Nov 11, 2013 10:05 am
Subject: [GPSCC-chat] The Greatest Generation?
I was inclined to think so until
I recognized that they were not even
smart enough to put wheels and a
collapsible handle on their luggage
--why should they be when Red
Caps did all that for them? Of course
my disillusionment with the
Greatest doesn't change my evaluation of
the Shittiest, my deGeneration,
the one that climbed with
Martin
Luther King out
of the abyss to peer from the ridgetop, and then
stepped
back from the brink of the
Promised Land to settle for cocaine and
luxury SUVs and McMansions
instead of making the dream true.
We did succeed in preventing the
war against Nicaragua, and probably
we aided the liberation of South
America such that US-backed torturers
can now be prosecuted in Chile
and Argentina, and victims of US -backed
torturers could become
presidents in Chile (Bachelet), Uruguay (Mujica)
and Brazil (da Silva and
Rouseff). But Hollywood wars in Grenada and
Panama and Kuwait enable the
propagandists to claim we accomplished
nothing, and that claim enabled
the current crop of corrupt wars that
continue today in Bush's fourth
term.
Here's Professor Francis Boyle's
poetic rant:
The Greatest Generation?
Oh really?
If they were so great
Then why did they send
Their Sons so willingly
Off to die
In Vietnam
A war they started
While we suffered from
58,000 young men
Of my generation
Were murdered
By The Greatest Generation
Hundreds of Thousands
Of our Lives were destroyed
Plus
3 million genocided Vietnamese
Not that “gooks” mattered to The
Greatest Generation
Then neither did we their Sons
Why didn’t The Greatest
Generation
Rise up as One
And tell the American Empire
That you will not have our Sons
Over our dead bodies!
Hell no!
They will not go!
Why did The Greatest Generation
Not fight for US their Sons
Against the American Empire
As they did against the German
and Japanese Empires
We the Sons of the Greatest
Generation were not worth it
They said they were liberating
Peoples in Foreign Lands
Then why did The Greatest
Generation send their Sons
To fight and die
In that God-forsaken Land?
And to murder millions living in
their own
Land?
Was this some blood-sport
we had to play
With them as pony riders
and US as buzkashi goat
carcasses
Was it reverse Freudian Oedipal
Complex
Them killing us off
before we got to them
And took their place
Were we blood-sacrifice to
Moloch
With them as Priests
And we as sacrificial lambs
Were they our Abrahams
Actually murdering US their
Isaacs
In a Holocaust
To their Genocidal Yahweh
Hard to say
What was going on
In the Minds of The Greatest
Generation
If anything at all
Mindless Patriotism
The last refuge of them
Scoundrels!
They knew all about War
then sent their Sons marching
off
Into the Valley of Death
Charge of the Light Brigade
The result was predictable
A Decimated Generation
A Shattered Generation
MY GENERATION!
BUT WE ENDED THEIR DAMN WAR!
The Greatest Generation?
Hell no!
A Pathetic Generation!
May they ever be tormented
By Their Own Son’s Souls
Professor Francis A. Boyle
Francis
A. Boyle
Law
Building
504
E. Pennsylvania Ave.
Champaign,
IL 61820 USA
_______________________________________________
sosfbay-discuss mailing list
sosfbay-discuss at cagreens.org
http://lists.cagreens.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sosfbay-discuss
_______________________________________________
sosfbay-discuss mailing list
sosfbay-discuss at cagreens.org
http://lists.cagreens.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sosfbay-discuss
_______________________________________________
sosfbay-discuss mailing list
sosfbay-discuss at cagreens.org
http://lists.cagreens.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sosfbay-discuss
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.cagreens.org/pipermail/sosfbay-discuss_lists.cagreens.org/attachments/20131113/05b24a71/attachment.html>
More information about the sosfbay-discuss
mailing list